Flu Shot Lawsuits - What You Need to Know for Compensation
Experienced attorneys helping vaccine injury clients secure financial compensation under the National Vaccine Injury Compensation Program.
8 min read
My Vaccine Lawyer's Blog / SIRVA / How to Prove SIRVA and Get Compensation
Paul Brazil
:
Apr 27, 2023, 8:25:09 AM
Proving a SIRVA claim under the Vaccine Injury Compensation Program (VICP) involves showing that a covered vaccination was followed by shoulder pain and limited range of motion that meet the federal Vaccine Injury Table requirements. A Table SIRVA claim does not require proof that the person administering the vaccine was negligent or made an identifiable injection error.
The evidence must establish when symptoms began, which shoulder received the injection, whether a previous shoulder condition explains the symptoms, and whether another medical condition provides a better explanation. The VICP is a federal no-fault compensation program that allows eligible individuals to pursue compensation for qualifying vaccine injuries without proving negligence.
Medical records, vaccination documentation, symptom history, and treatment records help determine whether a shoulder injury satisfies the Table criteria and other VICP requirements. A SIRVA lawyer can review this evidence, identify potential gaps, and determine whether a Table claim or an alternative causation claim may be supported.
To establish a SIRVA claim under the Vaccine Injury Table, the evidence must address several specific requirements:
Meeting these requirements may establish a presumption of causation under the Vaccine Injury Table. The claim must also satisfy the VICP's severity and filing requirements. If the Table criteria are not met, an attorney may evaluate whether a claim based on actual causation is possible.
If you're unsure whether your records satisfy these requirements, you can have a SIRVA lawyer review the evidence and identify what additional documentation may be needed.
Here’s the key evidence you’ll need and how to get it:
For a Table SIRVA claim, shoulder pain must begin within 48 hours of vaccination. Medical records documenting when symptoms first appeared can help establish this timeline, even if you did not seek treatment immediately. Consistent accounts of symptom onset and other available evidence may also be relevant.
Action step: Tell your healthcare provider when your symptoms actually began, as accurately as possible. Ask that your vaccination date, reported symptom onset, and any delay in seeking treatment be documented in your medical record.
For a Table SIRVA claim, pain and reduced range of motion must be limited to the shoulder that received the vaccination. The vaccination record and medical notes can help establish which arm was injected and where the symptoms occurred.
Action step: Ask your provider to document which shoulder is affected and confirm the injection site when that information is available. If the vaccination record does not identify the arm used, tell your attorney so other available evidence can be reviewed.
If your vaccination card doesn’t list the arm used, contact the pharmacy, clinic, or provider where you received the shot. Ask for the vaccine administration record, which should include injection site details.
If the site isn’t listed, your personal statement and the consistent reporting in your medical records can still be used, but it’s stronger if confirmed.
The Vaccine Injury Table requires that there be no prior history of pain, inflammation, or dysfunction in the affected shoulder that would explain the symptoms following vaccination. A previous shoulder diagnosis does not automatically exclude a claim, but the earlier condition and its relationship to the current symptoms must be evaluated.
Provide an accurate history of any previous shoulder injuries, pain, treatment, or imaging. Earlier medical records may help distinguish a new shoulder problem from a preexisting condition or another explanation for the symptoms.
Medical evaluations may identify conditions such as bursitis, adhesive capsulitis (frozen shoulder), rotator cuff injuries, or shoulder tendonitis. However, these conditions can also develop for reasons unrelated to vaccination.
A diagnosis alone does not establish a Table SIRVA claim. The complete symptom history, timing of onset, prior shoulder condition, physical examination, and alternative medical explanations must also be considered.
Discuss your symptoms and vaccination history with your healthcare provider. Accurate examination findings, clinical notes, and diagnostic records can help your attorney evaluate whether the injury meets the federal SIRVA definition.
An MRI or ultrasound may help identify inflammation, tendon injuries, or other shoulder abnormalities. However, imaging is not always required for a SIRVA claim, and imaging findings alone cannot establish that vaccination caused the injury. The results must be considered alongside the symptom timeline, physical examination, prior shoulder history, and other possible causes.
Action step: Ask your healthcare provider whether imaging is medically appropriate for your symptoms. If imaging has already been performed, retain the reports and discuss the findings with your attorney.
Treatment records can help document the duration of symptoms, functional limitations, and care received for the shoulder injury. These records may also support the VICP severity requirement and any claim for qualifying medical expenses.
Action step: Keep every receipt, referral, and note related to your treatment.
Treatment often includes:
Physical therapy records (dates, duration, and outcome)
Steroid injections
Pain management consults
Surgical reports, if applicable
The duration of treatment is one factor that may be considered when evaluating compensation, but the amount awarded depends on the evidence and circumstances of each claim.
Medical progress notes can help establish how shoulder symptoms affect daily activities, including lifting, reaching, dressing, sleeping, and working. They can also document changes in range of motion, treatment response, and the duration of the injury.
Action step: Don’t underplay your symptoms. Be honest, specific, and consistent. Use examples like:
“Pain when reaching over my head” or “Wakes me up at night”.
These details help your attorney prove both the impact and the duration of the injury.
You can request records yourself, but if My Vaccine Lawyer accepts your VICP claim, our team can help obtain, organize, and review the documentation needed to develop your case, including:
Requesting and organizing medical records
Requesting vaccine administration logs from clinics or pharmacies
Gathering billing statements, imaging reports, and therapy notes
Organizing and submitting everything to the Court of Federal Claims
The following records can help an attorney evaluate a potential SIRVA claim:
You do not need to have every document before requesting a case review. My Vaccine Lawyer can help identify the records needed to evaluate and develop a claim.
The Vaccine Injury Compensation Program (VICP) is a no-fault federal claims system that provides financial compensation to individuals who suffer a vaccine-related injury, including SIRVA. It is operated by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services and cases are handled in the United States Court of Federal Claims with oversight from a Special Master.
Eligible individuals seek compensation by filing a petition in the U.S. Court of Federal Claims. Depending on the evidence and applicable legal limits, compensation may include qualifying medical expenses, lost earnings, and pain and suffering. Awards are determined individually, and compensation is not guaranteed.
The VICP provides a specialized federal process for evaluating qualifying vaccine injury claims. Medical evidence, vaccination records, and the applicable legal requirements are reviewed to determine whether compensation is warranted.
More about the Vaccine Injury Compensation Program
To prove a SIRVA claim, the vaccine must be a covered vaccine, and your shoulder injury must meet strict criteria.
Covered vaccines include:
Influenza (flu) vaccine
Hepatitis A and B vaccines
Tetanus-containing vaccines
MMR, DTaP, and HPV vaccines
The Vaccine Injury Table recognizes Shoulder Injury Related to Vaccine Administration (SIRVA) for applicable covered vaccines. Medical records may also identify conditions such as bursitis, adhesive capsulitis, or rotator cuff injuries, but these diagnoses do not independently establish a Table SIRVA claim. Neurological injuries require separate evaluation and should not automatically be classified as SIRVA.
For a Table SIRVA claim, shoulder pain must begin within 48 hours of vaccination, and the complete Table definition must be satisfied.
Separately, the VICP's statutory severity requirement generally requires that the effects of the injury:
Surgery alone, outpatient treatment, or significant medical expenses do not independently satisfy this requirement. Other eligibility and filing requirements also apply.
An attorney can review whether the available evidence supports a Table SIRVA claim or whether a different legal approach may be appropriate.
Learn more about SIRVA and covered vaccines
More on Flu Vaccine Injuries
The United States Court of Federal Claims is the exclusive venue where all Vaccine Injury Compensation Program cases are filed, including those involving SIRVA injuries. Instead of going through a traditional civil court, your SIRVA claim is handled in a specialized process where a Special Master reviews the evidence and decides whether you qualify for compensation.
After a petition is filed, the Department of Health and Human Services reviews the medical evidence and provides its position on the claim. Department of Justice attorneys represent HHS in proceedings before a Special Master. The legal analysis depends on whether the claim meets the Vaccine Injury Table requirements or seeks to establish actual causation.
VICP petitions are reviewed through a specialized federal legal process. Some claims resolve through negotiated settlements, while others require additional evidence, hearings, or a decision by a Special Master. The time required and outcome depend on the circumstances of the individual claim.
More on the Vaccine Injury Court Process
Compensation for an eligible SIRVA claim depends on the medical evidence, financial losses, and circumstances of the injury. Under the VICP, recoverable compensation may include:
There is no guaranteed settlement amount for a SIRVA claim. The severity of the injury, duration of symptoms, medical documentation, and demonstrated losses can affect compensation.
Past settlements may provide examples of how claims have been resolved, but they do not predict the outcome or value of another case.
View real examples: SIRVA Injury Settlement Results
My Vaccine Lawyer helps clients evaluate and pursue SIRVA claims through the federal Vaccine Injury Compensation Program. If the firm accepts your case, its legal team can assist with medical record collection, petition preparation, case development, and representation throughout the claims process.
Here's how our legal team helps evaluate, prepare, and pursue a SIRVA claim:
We gather and review your medical records to confirm that your first symptom appeared within the required time frame after the vaccine administration.
We evaluate medical evidence and, when appropriate, work with medical experts to address causation and other disputed issues.
We prepare and file your petition in the U.S. Court of Federal Claims and handle the required legal documentation.
We communicate with Health and Human Services and the Department of Justice attorneys who defend the claim, and negotiate for the full compensation allowed under the program.
When necessary, we represent clients in proceedings before a Special Master in the U.S. Court of Federal Claims.
Our role is to develop and present the evidence supporting your claim, explain the legal process, and pursue compensation available under the VICP.
If you develop persistent shoulder pain or limited movement after vaccination, seek medical evaluation and describe when your symptoms began. Keep your vaccination documentation and any available medical or treatment records.
You do not need to wait six months before speaking with an attorney. Early legal review can help identify applicable filing deadlines and determine what additional evidence may be needed.
My Vaccine Lawyer has experience representing individuals with SIRVA claims nationwide. Our team can review your vaccination history, symptoms, medical records, and potential eligibility for compensation through the VICP.
My Vaccine Lawyer offers a free case evaluation. If we accept a qualified VICP claim, the VICP pays our attorney’s fees directly, separate from your award, and by law we can’t charge you any other fee.
Location
715 Twining Road, Suite 208
Dresher, PA 19025
Tel: (800) 229-7704
Email: info@myvaccinelawyer.com
Services
We only handle vaccine injury claims. We know how to prove your injury, deal with the federal system, and fight for the full settlement you deserve. Contact us today for a free consultation.
Paul Brazil is a native of Dunmore, Pennsylvania and a graduate of Dunmore High School. For his undergraduate education, he attended Bloomsburg University where he majored in political science. He then went on to earn his JD from Widener University School of Law. Following graduation from law school, Mr. Brazil worked at a large Philadelphia civil defense firm where he litigated workers’ compensation claims and Heart and Lung Act cases. In 2012, he joined with his coworker Max Muller to form Muller Brazil.
Experienced attorneys helping vaccine injury clients secure financial compensation under the National Vaccine Injury Compensation Program.
The Tdap vaccine is an immunization that protects against three serious diseases: tetanus, diphtheria, and pertussis (whooping cough). While the...
A VICP claim takes about two to three years, on average, from filing to adjudication. That is the current benchmark published by the Health Resources...